Monday, November 24, 2008

Twilight Movie (WARNING: this post contains spoiler information)




On Saturday we had a girl's day and my sisters, my mom, and I went to see "Twilight."

We had tickets for 3:00 in the afternoon, so it was good, cuz that was exactly when the BSU game was.....so there would be less people in theory. The theatre was still full, though, but we came an hour early so we got the seats we wanted.....front row of the stadium in the Majestic, so that we could put our feet up on the bar.....(we kinda had to run to get the bar first....that was funny). ANYWAY. People keep asking me if I enjoyed the movie and so I'm gonna tell you all about it. If you haven't seen the movie yet, you may not want to read this cuz I'm about to write a bunch of spoilers. Did I like the movie?.....Yes. I really did enjoy it. HOWEVER!! There were so many things wrong that I just HAVE to list them here.

First of all, I understand that when a book is made into a movie, the storyline HAS t be changed to get all the important events within two hours. I understand that, and I'm okay with it. What bothers me is when they change characteristics of the characters in the movies. The first time I got REALLY fired up about this happening was when Harry Potter 4 came out in the movies. That book is LONG and they changed all kinds of plot things to save time. I'm okay with that, but then there was the part when Voldermort uses the "imperius" curse on Harry to make him bow. Now in the book, Harry has the strength to withstand that curse (you have to have a very strong mind and willpower to do such a thing). It was a really big deal in the book that he could do that, cuz it's rare that people are strong enough for that. Then in the movie, Voldermort makes him bow.....AND HE DOES IT!!! WHY would you change something like that?!! It doesn't make the movie shorter, it just RUINS the character. No reason behind it, except the writer or director, or whoever changed it is just really stupid. So, what character changes was there in "Twilight"? Let me tell you!

1. In the movie, Charlie was always drinking beer. The book NEVER talked about that....and WHY is that necessary?

2. In the movie, Bella and Charlie always ate at a diner, instead of Bella cooking for Charlie. BELLA ALWAYS cooked for Charlie! That did not save time, by taking that out. Bella's cooking shows that she's selfless, and that she's used to taking care of other people.

3. The book hardly showd any level of how much Edward cared about her.....how much he was in love with her. In the movie, Edward took her up a tree......the book Edward would NEVER take her that high up a tree, because he's so concerned about her safety. In the movie, Edward always looked upset about something......when we know from reading the book, that this was the happiest time of his life.

4. The POLITICAL CORRECTNESS!!! Augh! In the movie, Tyler (the kid that hit Bella with his van) is black. Angela and Eric (who is supposed to have greasy hair and a face covered in zits) were ASIAN! Sorry, but in a town with only 3,000 people, there would not be that much diversity.

5. When Bella goes to the Prom in the movie, she gets ready at her own house WITHOUT Alice's help. Why did they do that? It takes away from the fact that Alice LOVES to dress people up, and that Alice is just DYING to become best friends with Bella. In the movie, she just borrowed the dress from Alice. Okay, if you can't afford to make another scene at the Cullen's house then they could have at least had Alice go to Bella's house.

6. When all the other boys ask Bella to the dance when she first gets to school, in the movie they make that dance the Prom. In the book it was a girl's choice dance. Now this doesn't seem like a big deal at first glance, but Bella turned down three boys for that girl's choice dance by telling them that she would be outa town. By making those boys ask her to the prom instead, the movie makes it look like she turned down three guys and then just went with Edward. Bella cares too much about everyone else's feelings to have done that.

7. HERE'S THE KICKER! When Bella has been bitten by James, and the venom starts to spread, Edward realizes he has to either suck out the venom, or let her change into a vampire. Well, we all know that he loves her too much, so he sucks out the venom and then stops just when her blood is clean. In the movie, they gave Carlile a line, "Edward, stop....her blood is clean." WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT?!! It takes away from how much Edward loves her! He stopped himself, because he loved her.....not because Carlile told him to. That REALLY bothered me.

8. These last things are just picky things. I thought the filming was pretty cheap-o. When James is holding Edward up by the neck against the wall.....his thumb moves across his face! I'm sorry, but your thumb would not be moving like that if you're choking someone. I thought the music wasn't very good, and I thought the Cullen's house looked too modern. It's supposed to be like this all-white plantation house. Just little things.

Don't get me wrong, I honestly enjoyed the movie, but they made unnecessary changes that upset me. I realize it's a first film and the budget was not what it should have been. But....I duno. Just so you believe me, let me tell you what I DID like!

1. I LOVED the baseball scene. That was totally awesome. Good filming, good music, good special effects. That was great.

2. I loved Emmett. They did a great job picking the guy, and I thought he played the character PERFECTLY.

3. I loved Alice.....I imagined her smaller in the book, but honestly your imagination is rarely reasonable when you try to put it in real life. I thought she was perfect.

4. I loved Bella. Just how I pictured her honestly.

5. I loved how they had Mike Newton call Bella "Arizona." That was not in the book, but it was cool, and kinda funny.

6. Good job on Jessica. EXACTLY how I imagined her.

7. There was a lot of humor, especially at the beginning when Bella and Edward are just getting to know eachother. That was very entertaining. And you'll just have to watch the movie to see exactly what I'm talking about with that one.

8. I loved Esme. They did a good job showing how happy she was that Edward finally found someone. She was always smiling when Bella was around. I loved that.

9. I loved the graduation caps on the wall....that was funny and creative. Probably should have been in the book.

Okay, I realize this got too long way too fast but hey.....freedom of speech. I had to voice my opinions. I did enjoy the movie, I just thought there were too many unnecessary changes to the characters.

7 comments:

Anna Beal said...

Ok Heather, so I might have to copy your ENTIRE POST and use it on mine. You pretty much described everything I felt about it too.

MoneyBonanza said...

Receive $130 Paid to You Immediately

The LWS Freedom program makes it possible!
Click here to discover how:
http://www.lwsfreedom.com/id/greentitan

Shelly said...

K, I just have to add this, b/c we were SOO not expecting it! Adam and I went to see it on FRIDAY of all days at 2:30. You wanna know how many people were in the theater!?! SIX!! That was including us! How awesome! I TOTALLY agree about the grad caps. I also LOVED Rosalie's character, very true to the book, but I think we got to experience it more with the movie. I spent the whole movie comparing it to the book, and trying to make allowances, and now I'm ready to go watch it again and enjoy it for what it is!! Overall, I thought they did very well portraying the important things from the book. My BIGGEST complaint was that the movie was so QUIET!! The background music was barely there, and overall, everything was just...quiet. It made the movie seem sorta slow-tempo. In the end, I'm grateful they made the money they needed to start New Moon!
Thanks for your review!

The Wight Family said...

It was fun to read your post, Heather! I haven't seen the movie yet, but I'm glad I have a heads up now. Also, it's adorable how your blog is decorated like the twilight series! Very clever!

The Laws said...

My favorite scene was also the baseball scene...I LOVED it!

Patrick Collier said...

Hey Hebs, now I haven't seen the film, and I probably won't at least not until some one has it on video. but I did want to comment about a few things you wrote. overall I agree with you about many of those changes made, probably by the director, as being unnecessary. The one that I thought you should know may not have been intentional was the casting of different races as characters, like the black guy and the asian. my reason for saying that is that as you said the film didn't have a huge budget and honestly in casting I am sure they had a very hard time being too picky. That is part of a budget film, you just have to take the best actors you can get even if they don't exactly fit your character. Now maybe they did do it intentionally and if they did you can be mad. I just thought you might want to consider that. But guess what? this movie has already made a ton so you can bet that the next film will have a bigger budget and be able to do a lot more. and you can always hope that with more money they will get a better director that will stay truer to the story and not change all the unnecessary stuff. Have a great day!

Meredith said...

Hi,
I don't know you but I came across your blog and had to comment on this post.

I totally agree with you on almost everything you said about the Twilight movie. Some other things that I remembered that went along with your points were:

3.How much Edward cares for Bella. I noticed, also, that they don't show this really enough in the movie. I remember that when he picks her up in Port Angeles after the run in with those guys and she tries to distract him my saying "you should put on your seat belt" he almost mocks her back. I understand it is supposed to be humorous (b/c he's immortal) but it bothered me. Also, when he picks her up to take her to school he honks his horn! I remember in one of the books he got angry at Jacob for honking at Bella. It was just really out of character.

4. I do agree with you, however, I believe/think Christian Serratos (the girl who plays Angela Weber) is Latino/Hispanic.

5. Also, isn't Edward supposed to surprise Bella with going to the Prom. I don't think that she should have volunteered to go.

8. About the cheapness of the film. I have heard that since Twilight got so much money (WAY more than they expected) that the next movie's budget will be a lot better. So, I guess, that is something to look forward to!

Thanks for the post. It was interesting!